Dateline: An obscure corner of cyberspace
What’s the Spanish word for “busybody?” That would be metiche, at least in Mexican Spanish, where the word can function as either a noun or adjective. And, at times, that word might well apply to yours truly, El Gringo Suelto.
The current manifestation of this personality flaw started when Google, owner of Blogger/Blogspot, found that its inferior blog-spam prevention technology was being overrun by ever-cleverer spam bots. Apparently some enterprising whiz kid had taught them to read squiggly text and photographs of house numbers, and thus the robotic hellhounds of cyberspace were unleashed to wreak their havoc.
So instead of, say, licensing Akismet from Automattic, owner of WordPress, or even simply copying one of its obviously better features (automatically approve any commenter who has been approved once before), Google decided to go down one of the more annoying roads possible: visual guessing games.
And they certainly didn’t make them easy. Take that, whiz kids! So now blog readers who want to leave a comment are required to jump over many a cyber-hurdle before their own contributions can be accepted. First, one must click a box “Prove you’re not a robot.” The first time or two I encountered such a box, I clicked it, the screen redrew and brought me back to the top of the page. “Done!” I thought, and went on my merry way. Only later did I find out that I was only part way home and that the comment was never posted.
So now, after clicking the box, I have to scroll back down to see my comment, and then go through a visual guessing game or two, based on the contents of very grainy, low-resolution pictures. These pictures are tiny, perhaps 100×100 pixels, so it’s hard to see what they are on a regular laptop or computer monitor. On a cellphone, it’s impossible, which is a pity since mobile is the fastest-growing part of the web. And, to make matters worse, not all nine photos are visible at a time, despite there being plenty of screen space on a computer. So one naturally scrolls down, but alas, the pictures don’t want to stay down, and then they jump back up and hide themselves. So it’s difficult to select the correct 2 or 3 pictures out of the nine, if you can even tell what they are.
And figuring out what they are isn’t exactly straightforward. For example, one recently asked me to click all the pictures of kayaks. Well, one of the “kayaks” was in reality a canoe, but clicking it turned out to be the right answer, even though it bothered my inner persnicketyness. Others have asked that I click all the pictures of food in a group that included plants that might have been food crops (but weren’t). However, the most recent of these (which finally inspired this post) asked me to click all the images that contained pie. But as far as I could tell, none of the images contained pie, except for the example image. Do you see any pie in the image below? Besides the example?
So this is where the metiche part comes in. After a few frustrating experiences with this anti-robot Chinese wall, I decided to try to persuade my blogger friends who were still using this ridiculous system to either switch to WordPress or to implement Disqus as their commenting system. About six weeks ago, I sent a detailed email to four of my favorite bloggers, basically saying that I enjoyed their blogs, wanted to be part of the conversation, but was increasingly frustrated by having to prove, re-prove, and prove again that I still wasn’t a robot. (Seriously, you can make 3 or 4 comments within minutes on the same blog and have to re-prove each time!) And I emphasized that WordPress is very easy to use with lots of beautiful templates, and that there were a lot of advantages to Disqus too, besides the robot thing.
Results from the email were mixed. Of the four, Tino of ELBLOGDETINÍSIMO, decided to switch to WordPress, and managed to import all of his old posts along with existing comments into a snazzy new template, which looks vastly more elegant than his old blog. Tino reports that the conversion was easy and he’s glad to have made the switch. By the way, if you haven’t read his blog, you should. He doesn’t post often, but as a native of Monterrey, and a fluent English speaker who mostly posts in English, his blog provides some nice insights into real life in Mexico. And aside from that, Tino is a great friend, and was my ambassador into Mexico on my road trip last year.
The rest of the results were less enthusiastic. One blogger friend said he’d look into it, but I’m still busy re-proving my human status whenever I comment on his blog. One other responded, but said it would be too difficult to make the change. And the fourth didn’t even reply. Oh well.
So I’m taking my case public! Y’all know who you are. Please, please, please…switch to WordPress or give Disqus a whirl. Or I’ll soon be forced to write fewer comments on your blog and more posts on my own blog.
And we can’t have that now, can we?
P.S. Some while back I wrote a post about commenting, which is very relevant to this post. You can find it here.
Florentino Gutierrez said:
Hi, Kim!!!! I’m sorry it took so long to reply due to higher-than-normal workload. We never had the chance to discuss my moving from Blogger to WP, but somehow after this change I became more and more busy at work, with little time to sit and put my ideas into words. I have to say also that I had not anticipated how I would feel after the change, after all I’ve been a blogger for quite a few years now. WP still looks unfamiliar to me, but I’ll give it a try anyway (as soon as I can recover my PW). I really, really hope the guys at blogger removed those stupid barriers when anyone wants to write a comment, they’re certainly not use and very bothersome. I came back to blogger a few days ago, set up no moderation, and posted something too. It’s written in Spanish this time because it came from very deep, something that I needed to express in words. Hugs!
PS Oppps, what’s wrong now? I’m trying to post this comment here and WP tells me “Sorry, this comment could not be posted.”….
LikeLike
Kim G said:
Hola Tino! Thanks for your thoughtful reply. Really, if you use Disqus for commenting, as a reader, I’m really indifferent between WP and Blogger/spot. The commenting system is my big beef (as you might have noted, hahaha). But I’ll have to go read your most recent post on Blogger. Since I thought you had moved permanently to WP, I deleted your blogger site from my blogroll. Should I put it back? Saludos y un fuerte abrazo!
LikeLike
colm54 said:
Kim, like you I am a lurker but I do comment on the sites I frequent too for the most part! Those captcha’s are very frustrating especially when you have to go through hoops and find your comment has been lost in the depths of time or the net-therworld. Sometimes the moment is lost and that window of opportunity has somehow closed or the thought has withered on the vine. I could write a book on lost opportunities.
Thank God for the digital keyboard, otherwise I’d have reams of remnants in the bin of crushed afterthoughts.
I must say you do have a way with words as does Mexpatriot and his merry band of like minded scribes. It is fun though to interpret the pictures of the painted word, to be enriched by the thoughts and experiences expressed in a subtle way on an otherwise blank sheet of ethereal paper!
Through Steve’s blog roll my life has been enriched by his reelers and writhers to misquote the “Mock Turtle” from Alice’s adventures in Wonderland and of course I get to see the musings and thoughts of other like minded souls such as the Mexile and his photos, (we share a similar camera) Joanna van der Gracht and Felipe on the mount to name a few.
And it is fun and enriching to scribble a few thoughts thanking the writer…
So thanks Kim G and keep up the good work Eh?
Happy Canadian Thankgiving
LikeLiked by 1 person
Kim G said:
Hola Colm! Wow, what a lovely comment. Thanks so much for the kind words, and taking the time to “un-lurk,” and share some of your own delightful prose. Saludos and Happy Canadian Thanksgiving to you!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Andean said:
Ha… I would have NEVER found that pie… or whatever the arrow is pointing to 🙂
LikeLike
Kim G said:
Hola Andean! As far as I can tell, there was NO pie. On that particular one, I just had to fail and wait for the next guessing game. Saludos and thanks for stopping by!
LikeLike
tancho said:
And here I thought I was the only one that had difficulties proving that I was not a robot.
I switched over to Disgus after being badgered by Felipe for awhile. My question is what is Disgus getting out of all of this, since they don’t charge anything and I don’t see any ads or indication of how they derive their revenue.
I always am looking for the “hidden” reason for providing that service.
Sadly when those verification things come up, unless I have my glasses handy, I will simply give up or quit the comment process, weighing the hassle of looking for glasses vs the value of my comments.
LikeLike
Kim G said:
Hola Tancho! I think (but don’t know) that Disqus charges big sites like Bloomberg (which recently disabled comments). But otherwise, I have no clue about how they make money. Still, it’s a very good service from a commenter’s point of view. And I’m glad you made the switch; commenting on your blog is a breeze. Saludos and thanks for stopping by!
LikeLike
Barbara Lane said:
Ah ha! So that’s what’s been happening. Not having a blog myself I’m not savvy about all this – however I often leave comments that never show up. I’ve not known why. I’d guess the ratio of those that show up vs. those that don’t is almost 50%. When I find a comment isn’t there do I re-write/post it? No. I just move on. Sometimes it was relative to the moment, sometimes there’s a new post up and the conversation is now something entirely different, sometimes I simply don’t have time, and sometimes I’m too frustrated with the whole she-bang to attempt again.
Thanks for shedding light on it all. Yes folks – I agree with Kim – please make it easier!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Kim G said:
Hola Barbara! Any subsequent comments here should be immediately approved. And yes, thanks for adding to the debate. After all, as Felipe notes, comments are the lifeblood of any blog, and if you make it hard to comment, you’re restricting the blood flow. But at least you now know the drill; whether you want to go through it is another question, hahaha. Saludos and thanks for stopping by!
LikeLike
William said:
I know that you are writing about me! LOL
One thing I’ve noticed about WordPress (from your blog and also from Mexile) is that there are spells when the “self-updating blog roll” doesn’t self-update. Yours still hasn’t recorded my blog post from last Wednesday.
Saludos,
Bill
LikeLike
Kim G said:
Hola Bill! Thanks for stopping by and commenting with no hassle, hahaha. I’m not naming any names, save for Tino’s. However, yes, it’s interesting you note the self-updating blog roll. Only yesterday did I discover that it has failed to update any number of blogs, while keeping others up to the minute. For example, Steve has made a post or two since his last post appeared on the self-updater, and none of the recent ImagineMerida.com posts have shown up either. I’m working on this and hope to find a solution. Meanwhile, you just made the best argument for you to use Disqus instead. Saludos and thanks for your thoughtful comment.
LikeLike
Felipe Zapata said:
The blogroll issue exists elsewhere. For a year or more, my posts can take up to 24 hours to appear on Steve Cotton’s blogroll. Before, it appeared almost immediately. Something changed somewhere.
LikeLike
Kim G said:
Felipe: I’m also surprised at how long it takes my posts to show up on the Blogger/Blogspot blogrolls. This last one took about nine hours, I believe. Which is strange, because on my RSS reader (part of the malfunctioning self-updating blogroll), the maximum setting to check for new content is about four hours, and most of the blogs are checked several times an hour. I’ve Googled around for an answer, but haven’t found anything satisfactory. Saludos!
LikeLike
garydenness said:
I have long been aware that there are issues with the auto updating blogroll that I suggested. Most of the time, it seems to correct itself of its own accord, sooner or later. In theory, it shouldn’t need correcting. Inoreader should pull the posts from the relevant websites and WordPress’ RSS reader should display the Inoreader feed. Obviously something goes awry from time to time along the way. Whether this is due to Inoreader (you could try another rss reader I guess) or WordPress, I cannot say. I’m afraid I have never found a solution, but left it alone to (hopefully) fix itself.
LikeLike
Kim G said:
Hola Gary! Thanks for the thoughtful reply. I did think about trying another RSS reader, though I have to confess that the moment I thought that, a fit of laziness set in, haha. But it’s oddly comforting that you’re as confused as I am. Saludos and thanks for commenting!
LikeLike
Felipe Zapata said:
Blogger has long been immensely inferior to WordPress in a number of ways. That people still use it is amazing considering that switching is not that difficult. It’s even easier if you simply link from your Blogger site and start fresh on WP. Blog owners, it seems, are fond of thinking that readers often go back in the stacks. I believe that to be delusional. Just start fresh on WP.
And, as you note, Blogger’s comment system is abysmal. There is an easy solution if you want to stick with Blogger, and that is to add Disqus. Again, not difficult to do. No high-tech skills required.
Like you, I have urged people who remain with the lamentable Blogger to at least improve their commenting with Disqus. They remain adamant almost always, or perhaps it’s pure laziness. Comments are the life blood of blogs, and why authors would make it difficult to comment is a challenge to comprehend.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Kim G said:
Hola Felipe! You are indeed preaching to the choir here. And I’m with you; at least go to Disqus for heaven’s sake. I use Disqus to make comments on any number of sites, and it’s very handy, and I can participate in a discussion without going back to the original site, too. Saludos and thanks for commenting.
LikeLike
Lee said:
We’ve had this discussion before. WordPress is supposed to ping me whenever I get a new comment. But it never does. OK, once there was a two-week stretch when I got notifications. Now, I find myself mortified when I see an unmoderated comment that’s been lingering in my queue for more than a day. It’s a plot from Facebook to make us all give up blogging and turn over the reins to social media.
LikeLike
Kim G said:
Hola Lee! That sounds weird. My little icon seems to light up almost immediately, and before I turned it off, I was inundated by emails when people left comments. By the way, the little comment icon stopped working for a spell, and I think it had something to do with Flashblock, which I fiddled with a bit (don’t remember what I did), and now it works again. Thanks for stopping by, and Saludos!
LikeLike
Felipe Zapata said:
Comment icon? I know nothing of that. I get emails when a new comment appears.
LikeLike
Kim G said:
Felipe: in the upper right hand corner of your blog (or any WordPress blog as long as you’re logged into WordPress), there’s a little “balloon” icon between your avatar and the search icon. When that turns orange, you can click on it and then see replies to comments you’ve made on other WP sites, and comments others have made on your site. If you monitor that, you won’t need to get all those emails. Saludos!
LikeLiked by 2 people
Felipe Zapata said:
Interesting, Lee. I never have that problem.The sole problem WP’s commenting system gives me is occasionally putting legit comments into spam. But that’s rare.
LikeLike
Kim G said:
For a while my notification icon was a bit funky, as noted above, but works fine now. But Lee has a super-fancy customization on his WP blog, so maybe that has something to do with it. You and I are pretty much the plain-vanilla customers with the standard-issue site.
LikeLike